Compare documented CBB profit, sides, totals, regular-season leaderboards and March Madness performance before choosing an expert.
The best college basketball handicappers should be ranked using documented results rather than advertising claims or one hot week. Rocketman Sports reviewed long-term CBB Trends, separate sides and totals tables, the completed 2025–26 leaderboard and every available regular-season and NCAA postseason archive dating back to 2008–09.
This ranking emphasizes sustained profit, return on investment, winning percentage, sample size and repeat top finishes. Recent performance is separated from long-term performance so bettors can distinguish current form from proven multi-season college basketball success.
How These CBB Experts Were Ranked
Long-term profit and sample size receive the most weight. Repeat regular-season and March Madness finishes provide supporting evidence. Smaller-sample win rates are noted, but they do not automatically outrank thousands of documented selections.
Best College Basketball Handicappers: Quick Comparison
| Rank | CBB Handicapper | Best Documented Evidence | Best Fit |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Kyle Hunter | No. 1 totals; seven archive wins | Complete historical record |
| 2 | Big Al McMordie | No. 1 overall and sides profit | College basketball sides |
| 3 | Doc’s Sports | $13,890 overall; record since 2011 | Longevity and sides |
| 4 | Mike Williams | No. 4 overall; 2021–22 champion | CBB sides |
| 5 | Kenny Walker | No. 5 overall; 2022 postseason winner | Sides and postseason |
| 6 | Ray Monohan | No. 3 sides; No. 4 in 2025–26 | Sides and recent form |
| 7 | John Martin | Three archive wins; eight top fives | Repeat leaderboard success |
| 8 | Totals Guru | No. 3 long-term CBB totals | College basketball totals |
| 9 | Zack Cimini | 58.2% long-term overall and sides | High win percentage |
| 10 | Brody Vaughn | No. 2 in 2025–26; 59.1% totals | Recent form and totals |
| 11 | Jack Jones | Nine archived top-five finishes | Historical consistency |
| 12 | Sean Higgs | No. 2 long-term CBB totals | CBB totals |
The 12 Best College Basketball Handicappers for 2026
1. Kyle Hunter — Best Complete CBB Historical Record
Kyle Hunter ranks No. 2 in long-term overall CBB profit with $16,179, a 1,359-1,094 record and 55.4% winners since March 2017. His strongest specialty is totals, where he ranks No. 1 with $19,514 in profit from a 2,113-1,752 record.
Kyle’s archive résumé separates him from the field: seven leaderboard victories, 10 top-three finishes and 13 top-five finishes. He won the completed 2025–26 regular season with $5,624 and the 2026 postseason with another $1,510. He also won the 2009–10 and 2012–13 regular seasons plus the 2010, 2013 and 2014 postseasons.
2. Big Al McMordie — Best Long-Term CBB Profit
Big Al McMordie leads long-term college basketball overall profit with $21,018, a 1,990-1,619 record and 55.1% winners. He also ranks first on CBB sides with $20,609 in profit.
Big Al won the 2020–21 and 2023–24 regular-season leaderboards and recorded five top-three finishes. Kyle Hunter receives the top overall ranking because of his broader totals and archive dominance, but Big Al is the clear long-term leader for sides and total profit.
3. Doc’s Sports — Proven CBB Longevity
Doc’s Sports ranks No. 3 in long-term overall profit with $13,890 and No. 2 in long-term sides with $12,254. The tracked record reaches back to February 2011 and includes more than 2,900 overall decisions.
Doc’s won the 2011–12 regular-season leaderboard and recorded six archived top-five finishes. This combination of longevity, sample size and profitability creates one of the most dependable historical cases.
4. Mike Williams — Large-Sample CBB Sides Expert
Mike Williams ranks No. 4 in long-term overall CBB profit with $9,111 and No. 4 in sides profit with $9,265. His sides record includes more than 3,100 documented selections.
Mike won the 2021–22 regular-season leaderboard with $3,338 in profit and finished No. 9 in 2025–26. His evidence is strongest for bettors who prioritize sides and substantial sample size.
5. Kenny Walker — Strong Sides and Postseason Results
Kenny Walker ranks No. 5 in long-term overall profit with $8,438 and No. 5 in sides at $8,769. His long-term sides record stands at 1,292-1,099 for 54.0% winners.
Kenny won the 2022 NCAA postseason leaderboard with $1,250, a 31-17 record and a 23.8% ROI. He also accumulated three archived top-five finishes.
Long-term rankings identify proven experts. The premium board shows which handicappers have college basketball selections available today.
6. Ray Monohan — Strong Sides and Recent Form
Ray Monohan ranks No. 6 in long-term overall CBB profit with $7,869. His sides record is even stronger: No. 3 with $9,343, a 1,008-837 record and 54.6% winners since December 2012.
Ray finished No. 4 in 2025–26 with $3,138 in profit, a 99-61 record and a 17.4% ROI. That blend of long-term sides performance and recent form supports a top-six ranking.
7. John Martin — Repeat Regular-Season and Postseason Winner
John Martin produced eight archived top-five finishes, seven top-three finishes and three victories. He won the 2016–17 regular-season leaderboard plus the 2021 and 2023 postseason standings.
His long-term sides trend shows $6,588 in profit across more than 4,300 documented selections. The large sample and repeat archive success are stronger than his overall long-term ranking alone suggests.
8. Totals Guru — Proven College Basketball Totals Specialist
Totals Guru ranks No. 3 in long-term CBB totals with $5,558 in profit, a 1,173-1,023 record and 53.4% winners since December 2020.
The service finished No. 10 in the completed 2025–26 standings with $1,920 in profit. Totals Guru is a specialist option for bettors who want over/under analysis rather than sides.
9. Zack Cimini — High-Percentage CBB Sides Record
Zack Cimini ranks No. 8 in long-term overall and sides profit with $5,361. His 262-188 record produces a 58.2% win rate and a strong 28.98 SC Score.
The sample is much smaller than those of the experts ranked above, which prevents a higher placement. However, the documented win rate and profit make Zack one of the strongest developing CBB profiles.
10. Brody Vaughn — Excellent Recent CBB Results
Brody Vaughn ranks No. 9 in long-term overall profit with $5,233, a 309-233 record and 57.0% winners. He also ranks No. 7 in totals with $3,382 and a 59.1% win rate.
Brody finished No. 2 in 2025–26 with $4,891 in profit from a 290-219 record. The strong recent season and totals efficiency provide a compelling current case.
11. Jack Jones — Repeat Historical CBB Success
Jack Jones has generated $5,051 in long-term overall CBB profit and recorded nine archived top-five finishes. He won the 2013–14 regular-season leaderboard and has five top-three finishes.
His long-term record does not match his exceptional NBA numbers, but repeated CBB leaderboard success over many seasons earns a place in the rankings.
12. Sean Higgs — No. 2 Long-Term CBB Totals Expert
Sean Higgs ranks No. 2 in long-term CBB totals with $6,828 in profit, a 437-334 record and 56.7% winners since January 2021.
He also recorded five archived top-five finishes. His specialization and efficiency make him particularly relevant for bettors shopping college basketball totals.
ROCKETMAN SPORTS IN-HOUSE CBB HISTORY
R&R Totals won the 2014–15 regular-season leaderboard with $2,348 in profit, a 57-31 record and a 23.9% ROI. Mikey Sports won the 2008–09 regular-season leaderboard with $2,524 in profit. Pure Lock produced three archived top-five finishes. Current selections should be evaluated using the latest premium board and updated records.
2025–26 College Basketball Handicapper Leaderboard
The completed 2025–26 standings provide the most recent full-season comparison before the 2026–27 college basketball schedule begins.
| Rank | Expert | Profit | ROI | Record | Win % |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Kyle Hunter | $5,624 | 19.4% | 162-96 | 62.8% |
| 2 | Brody Vaughn | $4,891 | 8.7% | 290-219 | 57.0% |
| 3 | Oliver Smith | $4,439 | 11.1% | 208-152 | 57.8% |
| 4 | Ray Monohan | $3,138 | 17.4% | 99-61 | 61.9% |
| 5 | William Burns | $2,771 | 8.7% | 164-122 | 57.3% |
Long-Term CBB Leaders by Category
Big Al McMordie
$21,018
1,990-1,619 · 55.1%
Big Al McMordie
$20,609
1,944-1,581 · 55.1%
Kyle Hunter
$19,514
2,113-1,752 · 54.7%
Kyle Hunter
Seven victories
13 top-five finishes
College Basketball Regular-Season Winners
| Season | Profit Leader | Profit |
|---|---|---|
| 2025–26 | Kyle Hunter | $5,624 |
| 2023–24 | Big Al McMordie | $4,170 |
| 2022–23 | Alex Smart | $4,652 |
| 2021–22 | Mike Williams | $3,338 |
| 2020–21 | Big Al McMordie | $3,365 |
| 2019–20 | Sal Michaels | $2,411 |
| 2018–19 | Bobby Conn | $5,586 |
| 2017–18 | John Martin | $3,437 |
| 2016–17 | Alex Smart | $3,265 |
| 2015–16 | Matt Fargo | $2,726 |
| 2014–15 | R&R Totals | $2,348 |
| 2013–14 | Jack Jones | $2,278 |
| 2012–13 | Kyle Hunter | $3,352 |
| 2011–12 | Doc’s Sports | $3,642 |
| 2010–11 | Joseph D’Amico | $1,348 |
| 2009–10 | Kyle Hunter | $5,766 |
| 2008–09 | Mikey Sports | $2,524 |
Archive note: The source dropdown did not display a separate 2024–25 regular-season archive during this review, although the 2025 postseason archive was available.
March Madness and CBB Postseason Winners
| Postseason | Profit Leader | Profit |
|---|---|---|
| 2026 | Kyle Hunter | $1,510 |
| 2025 | Doug Upstone | $2,038 |
| 2024 | Michael Alexander | $1,805 |
| 2023 | John Martin | $1,987 |
| 2022 | Kenny Walker | $1,250 |
| 2021 | John Martin | $2,130 |
| 2019 | Jeff Alexander | $1,841 |
| 2018 | Doug Upstone | $1,988 |
| 2017 | Rob Vinciletti | $1,682 |
| 2016 | Jeff Alexander | $1,118 |
| 2015 | Mr. East | $1,066 |
| 2014 | Kyle Hunter | $1,827 |
| 2013 | Kyle Hunter | $2,667 |
| 2012 | Joseph D’Amico | $1,348 |
| 2011 | Michael Alexander | $1,241 |
| 2010 | Kyle Hunter | $2,395 |
| 2009 | Jimmy Boyd | $2,479 |
How to Choose a College Basketball Handicapper
- Prioritize documented profit. Multi-season profitability is more meaningful than a short promotional streak.
- Separate sides and totals. Big Al McMordie leads sides, while Kyle Hunter and Sean Higgs stand out on totals.
- Respect sample size. College basketball produces large daily boards, making selectivity and large-sample evidence important.
- Compare regular season and postseason. Conference tournaments and March Madness create neutral-court and quick-turnaround conditions.
- Check current form. Kyle Hunter, Brody Vaughn, Oliver Smith, Ray Monohan and William Burns led the completed 2025–26 season.
- Confirm the betting number. Line movement can materially change the value of a college basketball selection.
The records used for this review can be compared through Rocketman Sports’ long-term betting Trends and CBB Leaderboard. Bettors can also review the source CBB long-term results.
Use these long-term rankings to identify proven experts, then check today’s board for available releases and updated betting lines.
Best College Basketball Handicappers FAQ
Who is the best overall college basketball handicapper?
Kyle Hunter earns the top complete ranking because he leads long-term CBB totals, won seven archived periods and finished first in both the 2025–26 regular season and 2026 postseason.
Who leads long-term college basketball profit?
Big Al McMordie leads long-term overall profit with $21,018 and long-term CBB sides profit with $20,609.
Who is the best CBB totals handicapper?
Kyle Hunter leads with $19,514 in long-term totals profit. Sean Higgs ranks second with $6,828, followed by Totals Guru at $5,558.
Who was the best CBB handicapper in 2025–26?
Kyle Hunter finished No. 1 with $5,624 in profit, a 19.4% ROI and a 162-96 record for 62.8% winners.
Where can I find today’s college basketball picks?
Visit College Basketball Picks Today for free predictions or the Premium CBB Picks board for currently available expert selections.
Data and responsible betting note: Records were reviewed September 22, 2026. Long-term trend periods vary by handicapper, and archived leaderboards include both full-season and shorter postseason samples. Profit figures use the tracking methodology displayed with the source leaderboards. Records can change as selections are graded. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Confirm current odds and expert availability before purchasing or wagering, and bet responsibly.